PREORDER: Starless Night Liquid Kajal

I sadly don't understand the good reviews of this. Bought this when it was getting discontinued last year, wore it maybe once or twice, and it wiped off my face way too easily, so I didn't reach for it much at all since. When I grabbed it for the first time in ages a few weeks ago, it was completely dried out, so I had to toss it, barely having used it. I don't know if the quality on these varies between batches, but I wish I understood the "best eyeliner ever" praise— this wasn't it for me.

My favorite eyeliner of all time, and I’ve tried a lot! Great saturated color, very easy to apply (perfect brush) and lasts perfectly all day. Also, stellar customer service and communication. Thanks for a wonderful product!

Inkiest black in the most easy to use applicator! This is the perfect liquid eyeliner for all graphic looks! If you’re more of a novice with liquid eyeliner, like me, it is very easy to correct any accidental swipes from a shaky hand.

Starless Night is the best eyeliner I've ever had. I was happy to see it was still available in the 10 pack! Unfortunately, UPS lost my order. I contacted Tanaïs and they were able to file a claim and send me a new pack <3 While I LOVE Starless Night, this pack also came with Bengal Green and OMG it is GORGEOUS! And the personalized note for my birthday totally brightened my day. Thank you Tanaïs!!

Loved the extra thrown in (i guess they ran out of boxes for this color). Very pigmented, long-lasting, and BLACK. Love it.